Home Blog LGBTQIA+ Terms & Definitions Pronouns and Inclusive Language Understanding Singular 'They'

Understanding Common Challenges and Misconceptions About Singular ‘They’

Navigating language around gender and identity can sometimes be challenging, especially when it comes to the use of singular “they.” For Rainbow communities and allies in New Zealand, understanding and confidently using singular they can promote greater inclusivity and respect. Many people encounter misconceptions about this usage, which can lead to confusion or unintentional misgendering. By learning more about the correct and respectful ways to use singular they, we can help foster a more welcoming environment for everyone, regardless of how they identify.

Singular they usage is an important part of respecting diverse gender identities and expressions. It’s common to face questions or misunderstandings, but gaining clarity can make a real difference. For helpful information and to deepen your understanding of this term, visit this resource. Embracing inclusive language supports visibility, empowerment, and connection within our communities.

1. Misconception: Singular ‘They’ Is Solely for Plural References

One of the most widespread misconceptions about singular ‘they’ is the assumption that it is exclusively used for plural nouns. Many people mistakenly believe that ‘they’ cannot refer to a single individual, which leads to resistance or confusion about its correct application. In reality, singular ‘they’ has a long history in English and is grammatically acceptable for referring to an individual whose gender is unknown or unspecified. This usage is also increasingly recognized in formal writing and style guides, acknowledging its role in promoting inclusivity and clarity. Understanding this misconception is essential for fostering correct usage and supporting inclusive language practices.

2. Common Challenge: Resistance from Traditional Grammar Perspectives

Traditional grammar rules have historically emphasized gender-specific pronouns like ‘he’ or ‘she,’ leading to skepticism toward singular ‘they.’ Many educators, editors, and institutions have been slow to adopt this usage due to entrenched grammatical conventions. This resistance can cause confusion or hesitation among writers and speakers trying to navigate inclusive language. However, contemporary linguistic understanding recognizes that singular ‘they’ functions as a valid pronoun for gender-neutral references. Addressing this challenge involves educating stakeholders about evolving language standards and the importance of respecting individual identities.

3. Misconception: Singular ‘They’ Is Grammatically Incorrect

Despite mounting evidence and official style guides endorsing its correctness, some still consider singular ‘they’ to be grammatically incorrect. This misconception persists partly because traditional grammar rules favored gender-specific pronouns and viewed ‘they’ as solely plural. However, linguistic evolution and usage data demonstrate that singular ‘they’ is both grammatically acceptable and widely used. Recognizing this misconception helps in normalizing the use of singular ‘they’ in professional, academic, and casual contexts, reinforcing its legitimacy and promoting clearer, more inclusive communication.

4. Challenge: Confusion Over Singular ‘They’ in Formal Writing

Using singular ‘they’ in formal writing can sometimes generate uncertainty about appropriateness, especially among writers adhering strictly to prescriptive grammar rules. Some may worry that its use appears informal or unprofessional. However, many reputable style guides, including the Associated Press and the Chicago Manual of Style, endorse singular ‘they’ for gender-neutral references. The challenge lies in balancing grammatical correctness with inclusivity. Writers should familiarize themselves with style guidelines and understand that singular ‘they’ enhances clarity and respect for individual identities in formal contexts.

5. Misconception: Singular ‘They’ Cannot Be Used with Singular Antecedents

A common misconception is that singular ‘they’ cannot be used when referring to a specific, singular antecedent. For example, some believe that using ‘they’ for a single person is grammatically wrong or ambiguous. However, this usage is well-established, especially when the gender of the antecedent is unknown or the individual prefers gender-neutral language. For instance, in sentences like “Alex said they would join us,” singular ‘they’ clearly refers to one person. Clarifying this misconception enables more natural and respectful communication about individuals, especially in diverse contexts.

6. Challenge: Navigating Singular ‘They’ in Multilingual Contexts

While singular ‘they’ is gaining acceptance in English, its application in multilingual settings can be complex. Many languages have gendered pronouns with no direct gender-neutral equivalent, making the adoption of singular ‘they’ challenging for non-English speakers and translators. This presents a challenge in global communication, especially for organizations promoting inclusive language. Addressing this requires cultural sensitivity, awareness of language-specific conventions, and the development of alternative strategies for gender-neutral referencing in different linguistic contexts. Providing resources and guidance on singular ‘they’ usage can help bridge these gaps.

7. Misconception: Singular ‘They’ Is a Recent Innovation

Some perceive the singular ‘they’ as a recent linguistic invention, but in reality, it has been used in English for centuries. Writers such as Chaucer, Shakespeare, and Jane Austen employed singular ‘they’ in their works, demonstrating its historical legitimacy. The misconception that it is a modern development can hinder its acceptance and usage. Recognizing the longstanding history of singular ‘they’ underscores its grammatical validity and supports its ongoing adoption in contemporary language, especially in efforts to foster inclusive communication.

8. Common Challenge: Ensuring Consistency in Singular ‘They’ Usage

Maintaining consistency when using singular ‘they’ throughout a document or conversation can be challenging, particularly for writers unfamiliar with its correct application. Switching between gendered pronouns and singular ‘they’ may cause confusion or perceived awkwardness. This challenge emphasizes the importance of editing and proofreading to ensure that singular ‘they’ is used correctly and consistently. Developing a clear understanding of its grammatical placement and antecedent agreement helps in producing polished, inclusive content that respects individual identities.

9. Resources and Support for Clarifying Challenges and Misconceptions

To overcome challenges and misconceptions about singular ‘they’ usage, individuals and organizations can consult authoritative resources. For example, the Rainbow Directory offers detailed explanations and guidance on gender-inclusive language, including the proper use of singular ‘they.’ Engaging with style guides like the Chicago Manual of Style or the AP Stylebook can also provide clarity. Educational initiatives, training sessions, and inclusive language policies further support the correct and respectful use of singular ‘they’ in all communication contexts.

FAQs

What is singular ‘they’ and how is it used in everyday language?

Singular ‘they’ is a gender-neutral pronoun used to refer to a single individual when their gender is unknown or non-binary. It helps promote inclusivity and clarity in communication by replacing gender-specific pronouns like ‘he’ or ‘she’ in singular contexts.

Is using singular ‘they’ grammatically correct?

Yes, using singular ‘they’ is grammatically accepted and widely used in both informal and formal writing. Many style guides, including the Associated Press and the Chicago Manual of Style, endorse its correct usage in appropriate contexts.

Can singular ‘they’ be confusing or ambiguous?

While singular ‘they’ can sometimes cause confusion, especially in complex sentences, context usually clarifies the intended referent. Clear sentence construction and context are key to ensuring understanding when using singular ‘they’ in your writing.

Are there any misconceptions about the gender identity of singular ‘they’ users?

Yes, a common misconception is that using singular ‘they’ implies a specific gender identity. In reality, singular ‘they’ is a gender-neutral pronoun that anyone can use regardless of their gender identity, and it is also used when the gender is unknown or unspecified.

How can I practice correct singular ‘they’ usage in my writing?

You can practice by replacing gendered pronouns with singular ‘they’ in your sentences, paying attention to sentence clarity and flow. Reading examples from reputable sources and editing your writing can also improve your understanding of proper singular ‘they’ usage.

Are there any common mistakes to avoid when using singular ‘they’?

One common mistake is inconsistent use, such as switching between singular ‘they’ and other pronouns within the same context. Additionally, ensuring that the pronoun clearly refers to the correct antecedent is essential to avoid ambiguity in your writing about singular ‘they’ usage.

References

Please login to post a comment.

Advertise Here

view pricing

The Rainbow Directory of New Zealand connects LGBTQIA+ communities and allies with inclusive businesses, services, and safe spaces across Aotearoa. Whether you're looking for support, community events, or Rainbow-friendly professionals, you'll find them here — free, accessible, and proudly made with diversity at heart.